- Evangelicals
- Mainline Protestants
- Black Protestants
- Catholics
- Other religions (about 7%)
- The nones
Plenary talk with slides
What's Happening in American Religion
Cleaned audio · slide-synced · about 52 minutes · captions available
Captions: turn on CC in the player (English VTT). Prefer offline? Use the letter PDF below.
Page intro
This guide is not for everybody. If religious data is not your thing, that is fine. If you want a clear map of what is happening in American religion, this is for you.
I sat in the Salvation Army National Advisory Board plenary where Dr. Ryan Burge taught on what is happening in American religion and what that tells us about American society.
I am sharing it because too many of us still lead with yesterday's map. Burge walks the data: evangelicals, mainline, Catholics, non-denom, the nones, trust, and where hope still shows up.
We built you a slide-synced, captioned video of his talk (about 52 minutes), plus the key takeaways on this page and in the PDF.
Watch it. Read the notes. Then decide what your leadership needs to stop assuming.
This is not going to interest everybody.
If you want this kind of information, here is what it is and why I am sharing it.
I sat in the Salvation Army National Advisory Board plenary where Dr. Ryan Burge taught.
He walked what is happening in American religion and what that tells us about American society.
I had the talk cleaned, slide-synced, and captioned for our members. About 52 minutes.
I am not asking you to become a sociologist.
I am asking you to stop leading with an outdated map if this is the kind of data you actually use.
Thirteen teaching beats
The six-category map
American religion is clearer when you refuse a thousand micro-traditions and use six buckets.
Evangelicals held better than the narrative
Share fell hard from the early 1990s peak, but the story is not simple collapse.
- Share fell from about 29% to about 19% since the early 1990s.
- That share is still higher than roughly 50 years ago.
- Intensity (weekly attendance) has risen among those who remain.
Non-denom is the second-biggest story
Independent and non-denominational churches are reshaping Protestant America in ways hard to count.
- About one-third of Protestants / about 13% of Americans (roughly 35 to 40 million).
- May approach Catholic scale in raw people.
- Hard to count. Often described as Baptists with a better website.
Mainline collapse
The historic mainline went from cultural majority to a thin slice of young America.
- From about 52% of America (1958) to under 9%.
- Seven Sisters membership cratered (example: Disciples down about 81%, UMC down about 56% after schism).
- Only about 5% of Millennials and Gen Z identify mainline.
Catholics: identity without Mass
Catholic identity is more durable than weekly practice. That gap is the story.
- Share down about 5 to 6 points in 15 years.
- Weekly Mass from about half to under 25%.
- Rise of cultural Catholicism. Intergenerational handoff of attendance is the core problem.
Christianity's center of gravity flipped
Inside American Christianity, weight moved from mainline to evangelical.
- Evangelicals: about 20% to about 35% of Christians.
- Mainline: about 33% to about 17% of Christians.
Trust is the hidden driver
Institutional distrust tracks who stays, who leaves, and who builds local alternatives.
- Gen Z is least trusting (about 75% say you cannot be too careful).
- Weekly attenders trust more.
- Non-denom rise and denominational collapse track localism and institutional distrust.
Religion's reputation lag
Public trust in churches did not crash overnight. It moved through three eras.
- Era 1 (to about 1985): church trusted more than other institutions.
- Era 2 (about 1985 to 2005): parity with other institutions.
- Era 3 (now): trusted less than other institutions.
Boomer demographic cliff
Many Protestant bodies are demographically front-loaded with Boomers. Funerals will surge.
- Huge share of many Protestant bodies are Boomers.
- Funerals surge in 10 to 20 years.
- UMC-style bodies risk down 30 / 40 / 50% members by the 2040s.
- Millennials would need weekly attendance to jump from about 21% to about 48% just to replace Boomers.
Nones rose after 1991
The nones are not mainly angry atheists. Most are apathetic, and replacement math pushes the share up.
- Flat at about 5 to 6% until after 1991, then about 28% by 2021.
- A recent dip is not revival. Replacement (Silent/Boomer out, Gen Z in at about 42% none) pushes the aggregate up.
- Most nones are nothing in particular, not atheists. Often apathetic, not hostile.
- Lots of residual belief (about 88% of Americans believe in something higher). Few want religion eradicated.
63 / 30 / 7 toward mid-century
Today's Christian / non-religious / everyone-else split is not locked in.
- Today: about 63% Christian / 30% non-religious / 7% everyone else.
- Plausible mid-century: about 45 / 45 / 10.
The God gap / pew gap
Ideology is now one of the strongest predictors of religion in America.
- Very liberal: about 60% none.
- Very conservative: about 12% none.
- Young people often cannot imagine liberal Christianity as a live option.
Hope path: horizontal and vertical
Even skeptical generations still affirm that churches strengthen community and help the poor.
- Even Gen Z and many nones affirm churches strengthen community and help the poor.
- Lean into horizontal (social) and vertical (salvation) mission together.
- Friends and community keep people, not preaching alone.
Source teaching
Presentation by Dr. Ryan Burge · Graphs About Religion · Salvation Army NAB plenary. Educational paraphrase and mentoring packaging by Rick & Isabella Piña Coaching for Patreon members. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Dr. Burge, Graphs About Religion, or The Salvation Army. Members should watch the full talk on this page.
Print the letter notes
Same thirteen beats in a dense letter PDF for study and discussion.